Psychiatr News December 16, 2005
Volume 40, Number 24, page 19
© 2005 American Psychiatric Association
Integrating MH, Other Care Could Reduce Medicaid Costs
Rich Daly
The greater costs incurred by Medicaid beneficiaries with mental illness
should encourage policymakers to implement changes that would better integrate
patients' overall health care for cost savings.
Nearly 40 percent of Colorado Medicaid recipients had a psychiatric
diagnosis, and they incurred twice as much in total health care costs than
those without a psychiatric diagnosis between January and December 2000,
according to a recent study.
The cross-sectional observational analysis of adult beneficiaries in a
Colorado Medicaid health maintenance organization (HMO) looked at claims data
of 6,500 Medicaid beneficiaries eligible for services in both the HMO and a
behavioral health carveout program.
The study was published in the November Psychiatric Services. It
echoed the findings of previous research that found patterns of elevated
general health costs in people with a range of mental disorders, but this
study extended those findings to a Medicaid program.
"Most people are struck by how big of an impact mental health has on
Medicaid and how prevalent mental health disorders are and how costly they
are," said Marshall Thomas M.D., the study's lead author and vice chair
of the Department of Psychiatry and Health Science at the Health Science
Center of the University of Colorado at Denver.
In the last 10 to 15 years, Marshall said, medical professionals and
public-policy experts have become increasingly aware of the importance of
mental health issues in general medical and primary care populations. But even
with that increased awareness, many continued to underestimate the importance
of mental health issues within Medicaid and uninsured populations, where these
issues play an even more significant role than in commercially insured
populations, he said.
The study found that 40 percent (2,597) of the 6,500 patient claims studied
included a psychiatric diagnosis.
Patients with psychiatric diagnoses had 2.24 times higher overall health
care costs than patients without such a diagnosis ($6,995 vs. $3,121). The
overall health care costs included medical and pharmaceutical costs. The
psychiatric disorder costs ranged from $7,284 in overall health care costs for
patients with a depressive disorder to $8,567 for patients with bipolar
disorder.
More serious psychiatric disorders, such as bipolar and psychotic
disorders, incurred higher costs through psychiatric treatment, while those
with more common conditions, such as anxiety, substance use, or depressive
disorders, incurred most of their costs through increased general medical
care.
The practical impact of a Medicaid system such as Colorado's, which uses a
separate carveout program for mental health services, is greater support to
those with serious and persistent mental illness, according to the study
authors. But the same system tends to keep less severe conditions, such as
anxiety and substance abuse, in the general medical setting. Only a third of
patients with a diagnosis of a mental health disorder on a claim form had
specialized mental health treatment within the study period.
Other conditions that may contribute to the lack of mental health care for
many patients who need it, according to the researchers, are the HMOs' lack of
mental health services and the behavioral health carveout organizations'
exclusive focus on mental health services.
"So in order to address the mental health needs of the two-thirds
that don't go to mental health providers, you have to develop ways that focus
on taking care of those issues in general medical settings," said
Thomas, who is also vice president for medical services and chief medical
officer at Colorado Access, a nonprofit Colorado Medicaid health plan.
Benjamin Druss, M.D., author of another study on costs of depression care
in Medicaid, and Rosalynn Carter Chair in Mental Health in the Rollins School
of Public Health at Emory University, said the study indicated that
accountability for the patient's overall health is urgently needed in Medicaid
systems. Overall accountability may help control the costs that mental health
care patients place on Medicaid, even while greatly improving the patients'
health.
"If you have certain interventions that might incur higher costs in
the behavioral treatment setting but improve care or improve efficiencies of
services in other kinds of settings, like medical care, it is very hard to get
those implemented in systems where there is no higher level of accountability
across the whole patient," Druss said.
The study is important, Druss said, because its finding that Medicaid
patients with mental illness incur higher costs comes as Medicaid is seen as
an increasingly important provider of mental health services, and states are
cutting Medicaid budgets. The study shows better control of the mental health
conditions of Medicaid recipients may make a major financial impact.
In Medicaid systems that use carveouts, such as Colorado's, the system
allows most mental health conditions to go un-treated because there is no
examination of the overall health of patients, Druss said.
"If we are going to be carving out certain elements of their care we
need at the end of the day to put the pieces together and understand how these
patients as a whole are obtaining their care," he said.
Thomas said the study may underestimate the true extent of mental illness
within Medicaid populations because there is little incentive in systems like
Colorado's to seek out those with mental illness within general health care
settings.
"Prevalence of Psychiatric Disorders and Costs of Care Among
Adult Enrollees in a Medicaid HMO" is posted at
<http://ps.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/content/abstract/56/11/1394
>. 
Psychiatr. Serv. 2005 56 1394[Abstract/Free Full Text]
Get information about faster international access.
Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2005
American Psychiatric Association.
All rights reserved.
Home
| Search
| Current Issue
| Past Issues
| Subscribe
| All APPI Journals
| Help
| Contact Us
| 
